Overall, I liked it quite a lot; the concepts, story, and characters are all fairly sound, but it's very much a rough draft and suffers from ailments big and small. Ailments ranging from overly-melodramatic prose and characters crying on every single freaking page (whoops), to plot holes, loose-ends, and middle-of-the-novel-storyline-floundering. Basically it needs some heavy duty take-no-prisoners not-for-the-faint-of-heart editing. My favorite thing (not).
Also, whilst I was reading through, I tallied up all the characters I cruelly knocked off during the course of the novel. I knew it was a lot, but man.
Death Count:
- Secondary Characters—6
- Minor Characters—7
- Specifically Mentioned Soldiers—2
- Unborn Children—2
- Group of Soldiers One—23
- Group of Soldiers Two—300 +
- Undetermined Amount of Soldiers—lots and lots
- Off-screen—7 + 1 cat
- Metaphorical Deaths—3
Basically, I kill everyone.
Well. Almost. :-)
No comments:
Post a Comment